This website uses cookies to analyze site navigation and improve user experience.  We take your privacy seriously, and never collect any personally identifiable information, nor do we ever sell or share anonymized data with any third parties.  Click “Great!” to remove this banner.

How an Environmental Group Aligned with Monopoly Utilities to Squash Rooftop Solar

Policy
Comic strip illustrating the absurdity of trying to kill solar adoption during the climate crisis

California’s legislative session has closed for 2021 and elected officials are beginning to discuss 2022 legislative priorities, undoubtedly strategizing about which groups will likely support or oppose their bills. As many California elected officials ran on progressive platforms, getting buy-in from environmental groups will be a big priority for many Democratic lawmakers.


One group that’s getting a lot of attention from climate activists is the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), which has a mission to “safeguard the earth—its people, its plants and animals, and the natural systems on which all life depends and has always been traditionally looked at as an environmental organization.” Historically, NRDC has been highly respected and considered a reputable climate organization, with taglines like “Earth’s best defense” and with big wins like preserving critical species and securing broad legal protections for wildlife and marine protected areas. In 2010, NRDC helped to craft the first ever national ocean policy, which improves coordination among states and created a National Ocean Policy. Internationally, NRDC worked with partners to develop a first-of-its-kind United Nations agreement that requires the regulation of bottom trawling. NRDC has done some great work in the climate space. 


NRDC was established as a nonprofit organization 51 years ago and its support or opposition is highly valued, however, its seniority and past wins have allowed the organization to support anti-climate, pro-utility legislation while still being regarded by many as a reputable environmental group, derailing legislation and climate policies. Why would an organization dedicated to protecting the earth support anti-climate policies? While it’s not well known, NRDC has a history of siding with the investor-owned utilities to advance a fossil fuel agenda, although more individuals and organizations are taking notice as of late. 


After John Bryson co-founded NRDC, he served as a commissioner for the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) and eventually went on to become the CEO of Edison International, which founded the Edison International Institute (EII). EII is a utility-backed organization, which has produced studies biased against rooftop solar and led the attacks on the industry over the years. Taking a deeper look into NRDC’s history, Ralph Cavanagh, a senior lawyer from NRDC, set up the “California Collaborative Process” in 1989, which according to the San Francisco Bay Guardian, enabled key environmentalists to "meet behind closed doors with top executives from private utilities to smooth over their differences and hammer out energy-efficiency programs.” 


NRDC has issued at least four joint statements with Edison Electric Institute since 2002 regarding all manner of clean energy policy, which NRDC makes no effort to hide. In 2014, NRDC made a deal with the utility industry in which the utilities would stop fighting the existence of energy efficiency and rooftop solar in exchange for NRDC's support for designing these programs so the utilities can maintain their profit margins. Beyond joint statements from NRDC and utility groups, NRDC has also worked with the utilities to draft anti-climate policies. For example, in 2016, NRDC and the utilities jointly filed for changes to the state’s net energy metering program, the rooftop solar agreement that has helped over one million California families, schools, businesses, cities and organizations to go solar. In 2019, as policymakers were debating whether or not Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) should be held liable for the fires PG&E caused, the LA Times reported NRDC’s ‘Cavanagh thinks state legislators should change the law so that PG&E and other utilities aren’t held liable for fires sparked by their infrastructure unless they’re found to be negligent. “Our utility liability rules are unworkable. They menace every utility in California, and they need to be fixed,” he said. “This is not just about PG&E, and it’s a mistake to treat it as such.”’


Fast forward to this year when we watched NRDC undermine rooftop solar by supporting the “kill solar bill” in California, Assembly Bill 1139, and submitting an anti-solar proposal for the state’s net energy metering program, which will determine the future rooftop solar agreement in California. Beyond that, NRDC has made attempts to derail the net energy metering proceeding by suggesting major changes to the tool that determines how the CPUC values rooftop solar.  Further, the lawyer representing NRDC in the net energy metering proceeding formerly represented PG&E for 15 years, and represented Pacific Gas Transmission Company, a subsidiary of PG&E, for two years.


Environmentalists and climate justice advocates are beyond frustrated with NRDC’s actions. Not only is NRDC selling out to monopoly utility companies supporting environmental racism and accelerating the climate crisis, which often impacts communities of concern first and worst, its actions are causing decision makers to cite “environmental groups support {insert anti-solar initiative}” when in reality, it’s just one so-called environmental group that has a long-standing track record supporting the investor-owned utility companies. NRDC prioritizing that relationship over advocating to keep a proven climate solution an option for California, is not only disappointing, it has major consequences for environmental justice and climate policies. 


When asked about the hypocrisy of NRDC’s disingenuous equity claims about rooftop solar, citing the Vibrant Energy study that shows rooftop solar reduces costs for all ratepayers, and pointing out that the top reasons electricity rates are increasing are because of infrastructure that investor-owned utilities get a guaranteed return on investment on and fire-related costs, NRDC did not address or refute our points and did not provide any facts to defend the organization’s stance. When we asked why over 100 climate and equity organizations opposed Assembly Bill 1139 yet NRDC was the only “environmental group” supporting it, an NRDC employee responded by insinuating that their organization understood the issue better than traditional environmental organizations, which weren’t aware of what exactly they were signing on to. That is not factual and is an insult to the organizations, now a broad, diverse coalition of more than 350 nonprofits, small businesses, labor unions, faith-based groups and other members, many of which meet on a monthly basis to save rooftop solar.


It is clear that NRDC works to push investor-owned utility agendas, therefore it is extremely dangerous for NRDC to continue being characterized as an environmental organization and utilized by decision makers to pass anti-climate legislation and policies during a climate emergency when we need to move away from fossil fuels and towards zero carbon. We urge legislators, CPUC commissioners and other elected officials to not mistake buy-in from NRDC as buy-in from environmental groups, because NRDC does not represent the vast majority of environmental groups nor do NRDC’s actions show it's truly trying to end climate injustices and the climate crisis. Please help us fight for a more just and livable future by spreading the word and by reaching out to NRDC, asking the organization to support rooftop solar as a solution to reduce climate racism and to slow the impacts of the climate crisis. To join us in protecting rooftop solar, please visit www.HelpCleanEnergy.org.

All Posts

Category
Select field
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Your Vote, Our Planet: Why Civic Participation Matters for a Just and Livable Future

From the energy powering our communities to the air we breathe and the water we drink, environmental policies shape our everyday lives. Elections give voters an opportunity to influence the decisions that affect our environment, public health and future generations.

From the energy powering our communities to the air we breathe and the water we drink, environmental policies shape our everyday lives. Elections give voters an opportunity to influence the decisions that affect our environment, public health and future generations. 

‍

Yet millions of Americans who care deeply about environmental protection do not consistently participate in elections.

‍

‍

The Missing Environmental Vote

‍

According to the Environmental Voter Project, around 11.2 million labeled environmentalists did not take part in the 2024 Presidential Election. Voter participation is often even lower in the midterm, state and local elections. This highlights the gap between environmental concern and civic participation, as well as the potential impact of increased voter engagement. 

‍

One initiative addressing this gap is Patagonia’s 11.2 Million Vote Project, which encourages people to help friends and family make plans to vote.  The company announced the commitment of up to $11.2 million in $100 credits towards Patagonia products or donation to the League of Conservation Voters for helping three people make voting plans. Affording to Patagonia, as of September 30th, 2026, around 500K people had made plans to vote in this year's election, and the incentive allocation was fully exhausted as of that date.

‍

‍

Climate Change Belongs in the Political Conversation

‍

Another important message emerging from environmental advocacy is that climate change should be more prioritized in political conversations.

‍

According to a September 2026 Environmental Voter Project poll, 59% of likely voters surveyed across eight battleground states wanted politicians to talk more about climate change and pollution, compared with 17% who wanted less discussion. Environmental concerns are relevant to discussions about public health, economic development, energy costs, infrastructure, agriculture and the long-term well-being of communities.

‍

Climate change affects more than the natural environment. It intersects with everyday issues that influence people's lives, making it an important subject for public discussion and legislative consideration.

‍

Voters deserve to know where candidates stand on environmental issues, what policies they support, and how they intend to address environmental challenges. Likewise, elected officials should understand that environmental protection is an issue voters may consider when evaluating candidates and proposed legislation.

‍

Keeping climate change in the conversation helps ensure that environmental policies, proposed solutions, and long-term consequences receive meaningful public attention.

‍

‍

Why Voting for Environmental Legislation Matters

‍

Environmental legislation and public funding decisions can influence conservation efforts, energy development, community resilience, pollution standards and climate initiatives for years to come.

‍

When researching candidates and ballot measures, voters can consider several important areas:

‍

  • Climate change and emissions: Policies addressing greenhouse gas emissions, climate resilience, and the transition to cleaner energy.
  • Renewable energy: Initiatives supporting solar, wind, and other renewable energy sources, along with energy efficiency.
  • Public lands protection: Legislation focused on preserving national parks, forests, oceans, wildlife habitats, and other natural resources.
  • Clean water and air: Policies designed to reduce pollution, protect drinking water, and improve environmental health.
  • Wildlife and biodiversity: Initiatives supporting habitat restoration, species conservation, and the protection of ecosystems.
  • Environmental justice: Policies addressing the disproportionate environmental burdens experienced by certain communities.
  • ‍

Voting with environmental issues in mind means looking beyond campaign slogans. It means researching candidates' voting records, understanding proposed legislation, reviewing ballot initiatives, and considering the potential environmental effects of different policy approaches.

‍

Being an informed voter also means evaluating the practical details of proposed solutions, including their costs, benefits, implementation, and long-term impact.

‍

‍

Overcoming Environmental Hopelessness and Apathy

‍

It is easy to feel overwhelmed by the scale of today's environmental challenges. Headlines about extreme weather, biodiversity loss, deforestation, and pollution can make the future seem uncertain.

‍

Sometimes, that uncertainty leads to hopelessness or the belief that one person's actions cannot make a meaningful difference.

‍

However, disengagement means giving up an opportunity to participate in decisions that affect our environment.

‍

Voting offers a constructive way to turn concern into civic participation. It gives individuals an opportunity to express their priorities and contribute to the public decisions that influence environmental policy.

‍

And participation does not have to stop with casting a ballot. We can encourage friends and family to register, share reliable voting resources, attend community meetings, contact elected representatives, and support local environmental initiatives.

‍

Collective participation helps bring environmental concerns into broader public discussions and keeps elected officials aware of the issues their constituents care about.

‍

‍

Creating a More Environmentally Responsible Future

‍

Environmental protection is a shared responsibility that requires participation from individuals, businesses, communities, and governments.

‍

Organizations such as Patagonia demonstrate how businesses can use their platforms to encourage environmental awareness and civic engagement. The 11.2 Million Vote Project illustrates how environmental organizations and businesses can encourage civic engagement and help people make plans to vote.

‍

At the same time, the message that climate change belongs in political conversations reminds us that environmental issues should remain part of the public dialogue. Voters should have opportunities to understand the environmental implications of proposed policies and make informed decisions about the future they want to help shape.

‍

No single election or piece of legislation will resolve every environmental challenge. Progress requires continued engagement, thoughtful policy discussions, accountability, and participation over time.

‍

‍

Your Voice Matters. Your Vote Matters

‍

If we want environmental protection, climate action, clean energy, and conservation to remain priorities, we need to make sure these issues are part of our democratic process.

‍

For reliable, nonpartisan election information, visit www.vote.gov to learn about voter registration. Start by learning about the candidates and initiatives on your ballot. Research their environmental positions, understand the legislation being proposed, and make a voting plan. Encourage others to participate and keep environmental issues part of everyday conversations.

‍

The 11.2 million environmentalists who did not vote in 2024 represent a significant reminder of the importance of participation. Caring about the planet is meaningful, but translating that concern into informed civic engagement creates another opportunity to influence its future.

‍

A sustainable future is shaped not only by the choices we make in our daily lives, but also by the policies and decisions we support through our participation in democracy.

‍

We cannot afford to let environmental concerns go unheard. Let's stay informed, stay engaged, and make our voices count.

‍

Your vote is more than a personal choice. It is an opportunity to participate in shaping the future of our planet.

‍

Links:

Patagonia's 11.2 Million Vote Project: www.patagonia.com/elections

Climate change and voter engagement: www.environmentalvoter.org/updates/2026BattlegroundPoll 

‍

Read more

Powering Possibilities: How One Connection Sparked Nonprofit Solar Projects Across San Diego County

The Boys & Girls Clubs of Northwest San Diego celebrates a new solar power and battery storage system projected to save nearly $900,000, freeing up resources for youth development, food assistance and programs for adults with disabilities.

What began as a conversation about a potential grant opportunity has grown into a series of clean energy projects benefiting Boys & Girls Clubs across San Diego County.

‍

On October 27, Hammond Climate Solutions Foundation (HCSF) joined Boys & Girls Clubs of Northwest San Diego, Oceanside Deputy Mayor Eric Joyce, funding partners, club members and community members to celebrate the completion of a 50.4-kilowatt solar power system paired with 100 kilowatt-hours of battery storage at the Club's Oceanside location.

‍

The system is projected to save the nonprofit approximately $894,000 in utility costs over its 25-year expected lifetime, freeing up resources to support youth development, programs for adults with developmental disabilities and food assistance for community members experiencing food insecurity.

‍

But the story behind this project extends well beyond the solar installation.

‍

How One Connection Led to Another

‍

Our relationship with Boys & Girls Clubs of Northwest San Diego began when we reached out about a grant opportunity offered by an Oceanside-based foundation in 2024. Although that particular funding opportunity wasn't a fit for solar, the conversation opened the door to something bigger.

‍

The club introduced us to Boys & Girls Clubs of South County, where we began exploring opportunities to help reduce energy costs and expand access to clean energy through San Diego Community Power’s Community Clean Energy Grant Program.

‍

That connection ultimately led to us securing funding for the solar power and battery storage project at the Imperial Beach Club, where a 25.5-kilowatt solar power system and 54 kilowatt-hours of battery storage are helping the nonprofit reduce operating expenses and strengthen its long-term sustainability and resiliency.

‍

Meanwhile, another opportunity brought us back to Oceanside.

‍

When HCSF was asked to manage the Oceanside Greenhouse Gas Reduction Program, funded by Preserve Calavera in partnership with the San Diego Foundation, we reconnected with Boys & Girls Clubs of Northwest San Diego to let them know about the opportunity to apply for funding. Through our Solar Moonshot Program, we also secured two grants for the Oceanside project, including support from BQuest Foundation. This time, with new funding opportunities and partnerships in place, they were able to move the solar project forward with 100 percent of funding secured.

‍

What started as an unsuccessful grant opportunity had come full circle, demonstrating how maintaining relationships, connecting resources and pursuing new opportunities can turn an initial conversation into lasting community impact.

‍

Nearly $900,000 in Savings to Strengthen Community Services

‍

The newly-completed Oceanside solar power and battery storage system will generate clean, renewable electricity onsite, reduce greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution, and help the Club manage its long-term energy costs. The battery storage system also provides greater flexibility in managing electricity use.

‍

For an organization delivering essential community services, these savings represent much more than reduced utility bills.

‍

“This project is an investment in both sustainability and the future of our community,” said Marineke Vandervort, CEO of Boys & Girls Clubs of Northwest San Diego. “Every dollar saved on energy is a dollar we can redirect toward programs that change lives. We're incredibly grateful to Hammond Climate Solutions Foundation and our funding partners for helping us strengthen our impact for generations to come.”

‍

The Club's Oceanside location serves young people, adults with varying developmental abilities and families experiencing food insecurity. Its kitchen plays a particularly important role in nourishing the community while creating opportunities for youth.

‍

“Our kitchen does so much more than prepare meals,” said Kierstin O'Kelley, Culinary Director at Boys & Girls Clubs of Northwest San Diego. “Each month, our young culinary team helps provide 4,000 free meals to local youth while gaining valuable paid work experience. Investments like this help us focus more resources on what matters most—feeding our community and creating opportunities for the next generation.”

‍

By reducing one of the Club's significant operating expenses, the solar project will allow more resources to be directed toward these vital services for decades to come.

‍

Celebrating Community Collaboration and Local Jobs

‍

Oceanside Deputy Mayor Eric Joyce joined Club participants, including adults with disabilities, and community partners for the October 27 ribbon-cutting celebration.

‍

“It's exciting to see a project like this come to life right here in Oceanside,” said Deputy Mayor Eric Joyce. “When organizations work together, we can make clean energy more accessible and create real benefits for our community. My hope is that this inspires other nonprofits, schools, and local organizations to explore similar opportunities.”

‍

The project also supported local union jobs through its installation by Aloha Solar Power, a member of International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 569.

‍

Beyond its immediate environmental and financial benefits, the installation creates opportunities to introduce young people to renewable energy technologies, environmental stewardship and potential careers in the growing clean energy sector.

‍

“This is what we're working toward: a future where clean energy investments don't just power buildings, but strengthen the organizations and communities inside them,” said Tara Hammond, founder and executive director of Hammond Climate Solutions Foundation. “With nearly $900,000 in projected savings, this project will help Boys & Girls Clubs of Northwest San Diego invest more resources in nourishing young people experiencing food insecurity, creating meaningful opportunities for adults with differing developmental abilities and expanding the essential services that make this Club such a vital community resource.”

‍

A Catalyst for Expanding Our Impact

‍

The relationships that began with this Oceanside opportunity have continued to grow.

‍

Since completing the Imperial Beach solar project, we've secured funding for another project at the Boys & Girls Clubs of South County's Chula Vista location, which will include a 19.36-kilowatt solar power system and 41.5 kilowatt-hours of battery storage. Recently-secured grants are also supporting electric transportation and electric vehicle charging stations at the Imperial Beach Club as well as climate education at both South County Clubs. 

‍

We're also now in conversations with a third Boys & Girls Club affiliate seeking funding for solar installations at multiple locations.

‍

These growing partnerships reflect something central to HCSF's approach: our work doesn't have to end with a single grant or solar installation.

‍

By developing deeper relationships with nonprofits, understanding their priorities and connecting them with funding and technical expertise, we can identify new opportunities to expand our collective impact.

‍

This philosophy also helped inspire our Holistic Healthy Communities initiative, which builds on clean energy investments to address broader community priorities, including healthier indoor environments, clean transportation, climate education and resilience. The pilot program is taking place at the Imperial Beach Club. 

‍

The Oceanside project was a catalyst for this expanding network of relationships and opportunities, showing how one connection can lead to multiple projects, new partnerships and greater benefits for communities.

‍

Building a More Just and Livable Future Together

‍

We're grateful to Boys & Girls Clubs of Northwest San Diego, Boys & Girls Clubs of South County, BQuest Foundation, Preserve Calavera, the San Diego Foundation, Aloha Solar Power, IBEW Local 569 and the many partners who have helped turn these opportunities into meaningful community investments.

‍

The success of this project reminds us that collaboration isn't just about bringing partners together for one installation. It's about building relationships that create opportunities for continued progress.

‍

When we invest in relationships alongside clean energy, the impact can extend far beyond a single project.

‍

Read more

Freedom Takes Root

Reflecting on Juneteenth, environmental justice and our shared responsibility to cultivate the conditions for life to thrive

Pictured Above: A photo Dan took of Former First Lady Michelle Obama’s presidential portrait by Amy Sherald at the Smithsonian Institution

‍

‍“Even though the story has never been tidy, and Black folks have had to march and fight for every inch of our freedom, our story is nonetheless one of progress,” said Michelle Obama.

‍

Today, we celebrate Juneteenth—the day in 1865 when the last enslaved Black Americans in Galveston, Texas learned they were free, more than two years after the Emancipation Proclamation had been signed. It is a day of remembrance, resilience, and unfinished work. A reminder that freedom delayed is freedom denied—and that liberation is something each generation is called to carry forward.

‍

As we reflect today, we're invited to ask a deeper question: 

‍

What does it truly mean to be free?

‍

‍

Perhaps freedom isn't only what we're liberated from.

‍

Perhaps it's also what we're free to become.

‍

To breathe deeply.

‍

To drink clean water.

‍

To take root.

‍

To belong unapologetically.

‍

To know that the place we call home has everything needed to sustain life—not only for ourselves, but for the countless beings with whom we share it.

‍

Our lives are shaped by what's in the air.

‍

By the water flowing through, around and beneath.

‍

By the health of our soil and its smallest helpers.

‍

By the canopies of our trees and all they shelter.

‍

By the pollinators, fungi, oceans, rivers, and relationships—both human and more-than-human—that quietly make life possible every single day.

‍

Liberation lives not only in our laws, but in our landscapes.

‍

It lives in neighborhoods where children can safely play outside.

‍

In rivers that run clean.

‍

In forests of emerald green.

‍

In communities resilient enough to weather storms together.

‍

In the places we call home.

‍

Because we have never existed apart from the living world.

‍

When communities are burdened by pollution, chronic disinvestment or climate disasters, ecosystems suffer alongside them.

‍

When forests disappear, waters are contaminated, species vanish, or soils are exhausted, people suffer too.

‍

Our futures have always been intertwined.

‍

Environmental justice reminds us that caring for people and caring for the Earth are not separate acts.

‍

They are one and the same.

‍

At Hammond Climate Solutions Foundation, we believe thriving is never the result of just one thing.

‍

Healthy communities are built when clean energy, healthy ecosystems, affordable homes, public health, youth leadership, reliable transportation and strong relationships are woven together.

‍

Because liberation is not simply the absence of injustice.

‍

It is the presence of the conditions that allow life—in all its forms—to flourish.

‍

This Juneteenth, may we honor those who fought for freedom by continuing to build a future where every person, every community, and every living being has the opportunity not only to survive, but to flourish and thrive.

‍

Together. Ashe.

Read more