This website uses cookies to analyze site navigation and improve user experience.  We take your privacy seriously, and never collect any personally identifiable information, nor do we ever sell or share anonymized data with any third parties.  Click “Great!” to remove this banner.

How an Environmental Group Aligned with Monopoly Utilities to Squash Rooftop Solar

Policy
Comic strip illustrating the absurdity of trying to kill solar adoption during the climate crisis

California’s legislative session has closed for 2021 and elected officials are beginning to discuss 2022 legislative priorities, undoubtedly strategizing about which groups will likely support or oppose their bills. As many California elected officials ran on progressive platforms, getting buy-in from environmental groups will be a big priority for many Democratic lawmakers.


One group that’s getting a lot of attention from climate activists is the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), which has a mission to “safeguard the earth—its people, its plants and animals, and the natural systems on which all life depends and has always been traditionally looked at as an environmental organization.” Historically, NRDC has been highly respected and considered a reputable climate organization, with taglines like “Earth’s best defense” and with big wins like preserving critical species and securing broad legal protections for wildlife and marine protected areas. In 2010, NRDC helped to craft the first ever national ocean policy, which improves coordination among states and created a National Ocean Policy. Internationally, NRDC worked with partners to develop a first-of-its-kind United Nations agreement that requires the regulation of bottom trawling. NRDC has done some great work in the climate space. 


NRDC was established as a nonprofit organization 51 years ago and its support or opposition is highly valued, however, its seniority and past wins have allowed the organization to support anti-climate, pro-utility legislation while still being regarded by many as a reputable environmental group, derailing legislation and climate policies. Why would an organization dedicated to protecting the earth support anti-climate policies? While it’s not well known, NRDC has a history of siding with the investor-owned utilities to advance a fossil fuel agenda, although more individuals and organizations are taking notice as of late. 


After John Bryson co-founded NRDC, he served as a commissioner for the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) and eventually went on to become the CEO of Edison International, which founded the Edison International Institute (EII). EII is a utility-backed organization, which has produced studies biased against rooftop solar and led the attacks on the industry over the years. Taking a deeper look into NRDC’s history, Ralph Cavanagh, a senior lawyer from NRDC, set up the “California Collaborative Process” in 1989, which according to the San Francisco Bay Guardian, enabled key environmentalists to "meet behind closed doors with top executives from private utilities to smooth over their differences and hammer out energy-efficiency programs.” 


NRDC has issued at least four joint statements with Edison Electric Institute since 2002 regarding all manner of clean energy policy, which NRDC makes no effort to hide. In 2014, NRDC made a deal with the utility industry in which the utilities would stop fighting the existence of energy efficiency and rooftop solar in exchange for NRDC's support for designing these programs so the utilities can maintain their profit margins. Beyond joint statements from NRDC and utility groups, NRDC has also worked with the utilities to draft anti-climate policies. For example, in 2016, NRDC and the utilities jointly filed for changes to the state’s net energy metering program, the rooftop solar agreement that has helped over one million California families, schools, businesses, cities and organizations to go solar. In 2019, as policymakers were debating whether or not Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) should be held liable for the fires PG&E caused, the LA Times reported NRDC’s ‘Cavanagh thinks state legislators should change the law so that PG&E and other utilities aren’t held liable for fires sparked by their infrastructure unless they’re found to be negligent. “Our utility liability rules are unworkable. They menace every utility in California, and they need to be fixed,” he said. “This is not just about PG&E, and it’s a mistake to treat it as such.”’


Fast forward to this year when we watched NRDC undermine rooftop solar by supporting the “kill solar bill” in California, Assembly Bill 1139, and submitting an anti-solar proposal for the state’s net energy metering program, which will determine the future rooftop solar agreement in California. Beyond that, NRDC has made attempts to derail the net energy metering proceeding by suggesting major changes to the tool that determines how the CPUC values rooftop solar.  Further, the lawyer representing NRDC in the net energy metering proceeding formerly represented PG&E for 15 years, and represented Pacific Gas Transmission Company, a subsidiary of PG&E, for two years.


Environmentalists and climate justice advocates are beyond frustrated with NRDC’s actions. Not only is NRDC selling out to monopoly utility companies supporting environmental racism and accelerating the climate crisis, which often impacts communities of concern first and worst, its actions are causing decision makers to cite “environmental groups support {insert anti-solar initiative}” when in reality, it’s just one so-called environmental group that has a long-standing track record supporting the investor-owned utility companies. NRDC prioritizing that relationship over advocating to keep a proven climate solution an option for California, is not only disappointing, it has major consequences for environmental justice and climate policies. 


When asked about the hypocrisy of NRDC’s disingenuous equity claims about rooftop solar, citing the Vibrant Energy study that shows rooftop solar reduces costs for all ratepayers, and pointing out that the top reasons electricity rates are increasing are because of infrastructure that investor-owned utilities get a guaranteed return on investment on and fire-related costs, NRDC did not address or refute our points and did not provide any facts to defend the organization’s stance. When we asked why over 100 climate and equity organizations opposed Assembly Bill 1139 yet NRDC was the only “environmental group” supporting it, an NRDC employee responded by insinuating that their organization understood the issue better than traditional environmental organizations, which weren’t aware of what exactly they were signing on to. That is not factual and is an insult to the organizations, now a broad, diverse coalition of more than 350 nonprofits, small businesses, labor unions, faith-based groups and other members, many of which meet on a monthly basis to save rooftop solar.


It is clear that NRDC works to push investor-owned utility agendas, therefore it is extremely dangerous for NRDC to continue being characterized as an environmental organization and utilized by decision makers to pass anti-climate legislation and policies during a climate emergency when we need to move away from fossil fuels and towards zero carbon. We urge legislators, CPUC commissioners and other elected officials to not mistake buy-in from NRDC as buy-in from environmental groups, because NRDC does not represent the vast majority of environmental groups nor do NRDC’s actions show it's truly trying to end climate injustices and the climate crisis. Please help us fight for a more just and livable future by spreading the word and by reaching out to NRDC, asking the organization to support rooftop solar as a solution to reduce climate racism and to slow the impacts of the climate crisis. To join us in protecting rooftop solar, please visit www.HelpCleanEnergy.org.

All Posts

Category
Select field
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Freedom Takes Root

Reflecting on Juneteenth, environmental justice and our shared responsibility to cultivate the conditions for life to thrive

Pictured Above: A photo Dan took of Former First Lady Michelle Obama’s presidential portrait by Amy Sherald at the Smithsonian Institution

“Even though the story has never been tidy, and Black folks have had to march and fight for every inch of our freedom, our story is nonetheless one of progress,” said Michelle Obama.

Today, we celebrate Juneteenth—the day in 1865 when the last enslaved Black Americans in Galveston, Texas learned they were free, more than two years after the Emancipation Proclamation had been signed. It is a day of remembrance, resilience, and unfinished work. A reminder that freedom delayed is freedom denied—and that liberation is something each generation is called to carry forward.

As we reflect today, we're invited to ask a deeper question: 

What does it truly mean to be free?

Perhaps freedom isn't only what we're liberated from.

Perhaps it's also what we're free to become.

To breathe deeply.

To drink clean water.

To take root.

To belong unapologetically.

To know that the place we call home has everything needed to sustain life—not only for ourselves, but for the countless beings with whom we share it.

Our lives are shaped by what's in the air.

By the water flowing through, around and beneath.

By the health of our soil and its smallest helpers.

By the canopies of our trees and all they shelter.

By the pollinators, fungi, oceans, rivers, and relationships—both human and more-than-human—that quietly make life possible every single day.

Liberation lives not only in our laws, but in our landscapes.

It lives in neighborhoods where children can safely play outside.

In rivers that run clean.

In forests of emerald green.

In communities resilient enough to weather storms together.

In the places we call home.

Because we have never existed apart from the living world.

When communities are burdened by pollution, chronic disinvestment or climate disasters, ecosystems suffer alongside them.

When forests disappear, waters are contaminated, species vanish, or soils are exhausted, people suffer too.

Our futures have always been intertwined.

Environmental justice reminds us that caring for people and caring for the Earth are not separate acts.

They are one and the same.

At Hammond Climate Solutions Foundation, we believe thriving is never the result of just one thing.

Healthy communities are built when clean energy, healthy ecosystems, affordable homes, public health, youth leadership, reliable transportation and strong relationships are woven together.

Because liberation is not simply the absence of injustice.

It is the presence of the conditions that allow life—in all its forms—to flourish.

This Juneteenth, may we honor those who fought for freedom by continuing to build a future where every person, every community, and every living being has the opportunity not only to survive, but to flourish and thrive.

Together. Ashe.

Read more

Community Members and Elected Officials Celebrate Clean Energy Resilience Project at Boys & Girls Clubs of South County's Imperial Beach Club

The new clean energy system will generate nearly half a million dollars in savings, strengthen emergency preparedness and support healthier futures for local youth and families.

Community leaders, elected officials, youth, labor partners, funders and local residents gathered Wednesday at the Boys & Girls Clubs of South County's Imperial Beach Club to celebrate the completion of a clean energy resilience project designed to strengthen community preparedness, reduce operating costs and create a healthier future for Imperial Beach families.

The project, a 25.5-kilowatt solar energy system paired with a 54-kilowatt-hour battery storage system, was installed by Aloha Solar Power, an International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 569 union contractor, and made possible through a collaborative effort led by Hammond Climate Solutions Foundation and its partners. The system will help the Club continue serving youth and families during emergencies and power outages while strengthening community resilience and preparedness. The Club is expected to save approximately $12,000 in utility bills in its first year and more than $465,000 over the next 30 years, creating long-term financial benefits that will be reinvested into youth programs and services. 

"For many families, the Boys & Girls Club is much more than an after-school program — it's a safe and trusted space where young people learn, grow and build community," said Stephanie James,  chief executive director of the Boys & Girls Clubs of South County. "This investment strengthens our ability to support the children and families who rely on us every day while helping us prepare for whatever challenges the future may bring."

While Imperial Beach continues to face environmental challenges that have drawn regional, statewide and national attention, the event highlighted a different story — one of investment, partnership, dedication, community resilience and hope for a healthier future. Project partners celebrated a transformative investment that will create healthier environments, expand educational opportunities and strengthen long-term resilience for local youth and families.

"Today's ribbon cutting is about more than clean energy. It is about ensuring that this club can continue serving young people and families when they need it most," said Supervisor Paloma Aguirre, who represents District 1 on the San Diego County Board of Supervisors and previously served as mayor of Imperial Beach. "It also represents a commitment to environmental justice. Communities that have experienced the greatest environmental impacts should be among the first to benefit from clean energy investments and modern infrastructure, but we know that that is not always the case."

The project also creates opportunities for hands-on learning and workforce development, helping introduce young people to clean energy technologies and potential career pathways in sustainability and the skilled trades. Following the ribbon-cutting ceremony, Club youth participated in a hands-on solar oven demonstration led by Jim La Joie, inventor of the All Season Solar Cooker and founder of SolCook. The demonstration introduced youth to solar energy principles, solar cooking, and career opportunities in clean energy and sustainability.

While the ribbon-cutting marked the completion of the solar and battery project, partners emphasized that it also serves as a foundation for future investments in health, education and resilience that will benefit youth and families in Imperial Beach and beyond.

"While the ribbon-cutting marks the completion of an important project, the opportunities created by this investment extend far beyond today's celebration," said Tara Hammond, founder and executive director of Hammond Climate Solutions Foundation. "Through our Holistic Healthy Communities Pilot Program at the Club, we look forward to building on this foundation by advancing healthier indoor and outdoor environments, expanding climate education opportunities and helping create an even stronger, healthier and more resilient future for the youth and families served here."

The Boys & Girls Clubs of South County's clean energy resilience project was made possible through a collaborative effort involving Hammond Climate Solutions Foundation, BQuest Foundation, Aloha Solar Power, IBEW Local 569, San Diego Community Power in partnership with the San Diego Foundation and Calpine Community Energy, along with philanthropic partners, donors and community members committed to advancing equitable climate solutions in the South Bay.

Read more

Oceanside Greenhouse Gas Reduction Program Continues to Deliver Climate and Community Benefits

The Oceanside Greenhouse Gas Reduction Program is delivering measurable progress by advancing clean energy, reducing greenhouse gas emissions and investing in community-serving organizations across the city.

Oceanside, CA  — The Oceanside Greenhouse Gas Reduction Program is delivering measurable progress by advancing clean energy, reducing greenhouse gas emissions and investing in community-serving organizations across the city.

Launched in September 2025, the current phase  of the program is already nearing completion on multiple projects just six months in. Funded by Preserve Calavera in partnership with the San Diego Foundation and managed by Hammond Climate Solutions Foundation, the initiative is part of a broader effort to strengthen local climate action, build community resilience and advance equitable climate solutions. Funded projects include solar and battery installations for nonprofit facilities and low-income households, along with expanded food recovery efforts that reduce waste and emissions while increasing access to fresh, healthy food. 

At the Boys & Girls Clubs of Northwest San Diego’s Oceanside Clubhouse, critical pre-installation improvements have been completed, preparing the site for a solar and storage system that will reduce long-term electricity use and allow the organization to reinvest savings into youth programs. Investments in youth-serving organizations are also creating long-term community benefits and supporting local union jobs. “This gift is about so much more than solar panels. It’s an investment in our community, our future, and the young people who walk through our doors every day. By reducing our energy costs, we can direct more resources where they have the greatest impact supporting youth,” said Marineke Vandervort, CEO. 

Similarly, the North County Alano Club has begun installation of a solar and battery system that will significantly lower operating costs and emissions.

“Since the 1960s, the North County Alano Club has been helping alcoholics and other addicts recover from a seemingly hopeless state of mind and body — serving an average 4,000 people each month in 2025,” said Dan McSwain, a representative from the organization. “We rely 100% on donations, usually $1 at a time, and operate on a very tight budget. The result of this grant is reducing our overall expenses by 25 percent, allowing us to not only survive but thrive for decades to come.”

In addition to clean energy projects, the program is advancing climate and food equity through ProduceGood’s CropCircle Collective initiative, which has already recovered nearly 3,000 pounds of produce and is scaling operations across Oceanside.

“ProduceGood is focused on climate and social equity. Through the generous support of the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Program, the organization will increase food recovery by 100% in Oceanside while increasing access to fresh produce for hundreds of families.”

The program also expanded access to clean energy for low-income households. A few lucky families were able to have no-cost solar and battery systems installed in Oceanside’s Communities of Concern. These installations are expected to deliver more than 24 metric tons of annual greenhouse gas reductions while lowering energy bills and providing backup power during outages.

“Through the Oceanside Greenhouse Gas Reduction Program, this funding enables the delivery of no-cost solar plus battery systems to Oceanside households, directly reducing local emissions while strengthening community resilience,” said Ben Airth, Policy Director at Freedom Forever. “By keeping climate dollars in the community, the program helps lower electric bills and ensures families can maintain power when the grid is stressed. We are honored to work alongside Preserve Calavera and Hammond Climate Solutions Foundation to make these projects possible and hope this success paves the way for similar climate investments in other cities.”

These projects demonstrate how targeted, community-based climate investments can reduce emissions, lower costs, lessen stress on California’s aging electrical grid, offer energy resilience and deliver meaningful benefits to the community.

Additional announcements are expected as projects reach completion and further impacts are realized.

Read more